The Court refused to test Malta's Article 56A.
The opinion of 5 July 2023 said the clause could not be used in Malta and that a first-instance enforcement file would close within six months. A Maltese court had already refused one funded judgment.
- The ruling
- Court of Justice, Fourth Chamber, 19 November 2026. Case C-683/24, Spielerschutz Sigma. ECLI:EU:C:2026:992. Language of the case: German. The request from the Handelsgericht Wien, decided on 16 October 2024 and received the same day, is inadmissible. Judges Jarukaitis, Frendo, Jääskinen (rapporteur), Condinanzi and Kornezov. Advocate General Emiliou, heard on 23 April 2026.
- The claim
- Spielerschutz Sigma Prozessfinanzierungs GmbH, Vienna, against Geissler Heilbock Hopf Ferox Legal Partnerschaft von Rechtsanwälten mbB. Refund of EUR 5,000 paid for an opinion of 5 July 2023, and a declaration of liability for funding between that date and 1 August 2023.
- The clause
- Article 56A of the Maltese Gaming Act, inserted on 12 June 2023. As the judgment states it, an action against a holder of a Maltese gaming licence is prohibited as contrary to public policy, and Maltese courts must refuse recognition and enforcement in Malta of a foreign judgment given in such an action. The trade press calls the amendment Bill 55. The judgment does not.
- The opinion
- Two conclusions, on the information before the Court. Article 56A was clearly and undoubtedly contrary to EU law, so its use in Maltese enforcement proceedings was inconceivable. Under Article 48 of Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012, enforcement proceedings before the Maltese courts of first instance are concluded within six months.
- The Maltese refusal
- 19 July 2023. The First Hall of the Civil Court rejected a recognition and enforcement request under the regulation, in proceedings Sigma had funded, invoking Article 56A. Sigma was notified on 1 August 2023.
The Court of Justice has sent a Vienna reference on Malta’s gaming amendment back without an answer. On 19 November 2026 the Fourth Chamber held the request in Case C-683/24, Spielerschutz Sigma, inadmissible. iGaming Business reported the result the same day and called the amendment Bill 55. The judgment uses Article 56A of the Maltese Gaming Act. This desk opened the English text, ECLI:EU:C:2026:992, and press release No 167/26. The release is marked unofficial and not binding on the Court. The account below follows the judgment.
The request came from the Handelsgericht Wien, the commercial court in Vienna, by a decision of 16 October 2024 that reached the Court the same day. The language of the case is German. The chamber is Judge Jarukaitis, as president, with Judges Frendo, Jääskinen as rapporteur, Condinanzi and Kornezov. Advocate General Emiliou was heard at the sitting of 23 April 2026. The operative part is one line. The request is inadmissible. Costs as between the parties in the main proceedings are for the Vienna court. The costs of the other parties’ observations cannot be recovered.
The dispute is a claim against an adviser. Spielerschutz Sigma Prozessfinanzierungs GmbH, a litigation funder established in Vienna, sued Geissler Heilbock Hopf Ferox Legal Partnerschaft von Rechtsanwälten mbB. It wants back the EUR 5,000 it paid for an opinion of 5 July 2023, on the ground that the opinion was wrong. It also wants a finding that the firm is liable for future loss from the funding Sigma did, between that date and 1 August 2023, of Austrian proceedings brought by players against Maltese-licensed online operators who held no valid Austrian licence.
Sigma funds those player cases. The Vienna court says the players may claim their losses in Austria under the national rules on unjust enrichment and civil liability, because the service was offered without an Austrian licence. Through its clients, Sigma has obtained many judgments ordering holders of Maltese licences to repay those losses, and it is trying to enforce them in Malta under Article 39 of Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012. As the judgment sets that article out, a judgment enforceable in the member state of origin has the force of enforceability in the other member states without a declaration of enforceability.
On 12 June 2023 the Maltese legislature inserted Article 56A into the Gaming Act, the Att dwar il-Logħob. The judgment states two effects. An action against a gaming operator holding a Maltese licence is prohibited as contrary to public policy. Maltese courts are to refuse recognition and enforcement in Malta of a foreign judgment given on foot of such an action. Bill 55, the name in the trade press, does not appear in the judgment.
Sigma commissioned the opinion in order to weigh the risk that amendment posed for its business, including recognition and enforcement in Malta of the Austrian judgments it funds. On the information available to the Court, the opinion of 5 July 2023 reached two conclusions. Article 56A was clearly and undoubtedly contrary to EU law, so it was inconceivable that the article would apply in enforcement proceedings in Malta. And, in accordance with Article 48 of the regulation, enforcement proceedings before the Maltese courts of first instance are concluded within six months. The judgment quotes Article 48 as requiring the court to decide an application for refusal of enforcement without delay. In reliance on the opinion, the Vienna court notes, Sigma continued to fund Austrian proceedings for substantial amounts.
On 19 July 2023 the First Hall of the Civil Court in Malta rejected a request for recognition and enforcement brought under the regulation, in proceedings Sigma had funded, and it invoked Article 56A. The decision was notified to Sigma on 1 August 2023. The referring court adds that Maltese courts, applying Article 56A, have rejected requests to recognise and enforce Austrian judgments given for players against holders of Maltese licences in proceedings Sigma funded, and that first-instance proceedings under the regulation are not concluded within six months. It also says no Maltese decision before it casts doubt on the validity of Article 56A or on its conformity with EU law.
The adviser says the conclusions in the opinion were correct, and that it was legitimate to expect the Maltese courts to comply with EU law and with its primacy. On that view, liability cannot arise from national case law contrary to EU law whose emergence could not have been foreseen when the opinion was given.
Vienna says the outcome depends on whether the adviser, in the opinion, wrongly assessed the conformity of the Maltese legislation with EU law by misinterpreting the regulation. It says the only legal question left is whether that assessment was correct or, at the very least, defensible. It says it fully subscribes to the adviser’s considerations on conformity. It still does not treat the point as clear. The Maltese decisions may reflect a manifestly different view of that conformity, and both parties to the main proceedings agreed that a reference was appropriate. The court asked five questions. The third is in two limbs. They concern Article 1, Article 45(1)(a), and Articles 46, 48 and 52 of the regulation. They ask whether those provisions preclude a national public-policy rule that excludes recognition and enforcement of judgments against a licence holder and against current or former officers and key persons of a licence holder, including where the exclusion does not depend on an application or on exhaustion of remedies, where it is justified by constitutional support for the private economy or by the operators’ contribution to national revenue, and where the activity is lawful under Maltese law. The last question asks whether six months without a first-instance decision, when the delay is not down to the parties or to third parties, breaches the duty to decide without delay.
iGaming Business describes an inadmissible reference and a dispute about whether the adviser had been negligent, and it prints the press release’s lines on independence and on the lack of any objective need for an answer. Those lines track the judgment. InterGame, the same day, writes that the Vienna court noted a mistaken assessment and that it referred seven questions. The judgment records five questions, and it records Vienna as sharing the adviser’s view while treating defensibility as still open. InterGame also writes that a Maltese court rejected recognition of the adviser’s observations. The refusal of 19 July was a refusal of recognition and enforcement of a judgment, in a funded case, on the basis of Article 56A.
Germany and Malta argued that the reference was inadmissible because a reply was not necessary for the Vienna court to decide the case. Malta added that the dispute was fictitious, the parties having, as it appeared, put together an artificial arrangement for the sole purpose of obtaining an advisory opinion. Both governments said the consequences would run past this case. If a person could commission a professional opinion and then sue for the agreed fee on the ground that the opinion was wrong, the parties could by agreement turn any abstract question of EU law into a question relevant to a dispute.
The Court recalls that Article 267 is a means of cooperation by which it gives national courts the interpretation they need to decide the disputes before them. The justification for a reference is the need inherent in actually resolving a dispute, and the ruling asked for must be necessary to enable the referring court to give judgment. There has to be a connecting factor, real and concrete, between the dispute and the provisions whose interpretation is sought. A link that is hypothetical, theoretical or speculative is not enough.
In reply to a request for information, Vienna said Austrian law has no liability regime of its own for lawyers, and that national case law treats lawyers as experts under Paragraphs 1299 and 1300 of the Civil Code, so those paragraphs govern. If an expert’s assessment is incorrect, the expert is liable for the resulting damage only in the event of fault. An incorrect legal interpretation does not engage liability so long as the interpretation is defensible, and whether the authorities and courts apply that interpretation is not decisive in judging its defensible character. An expert’s legal opinion is defensible, among other cases, if it is consistent with at least some of the case law or legal doctrine existing when the opinion was given. For the alleged lack of diligence in the opinion on Article 56A, Vienna therefore has to decide whether the opinion was at the very least reasonably defensible in the light of the legal framework and the information available at the time it was provided.
Under Article 267 the Court rules on the interpretation of the Treaties and on the validity and interpretation of acts of the Union. It does not apply national law. The lawfulness and proper performance of the reciprocal obligations of the parties to this consultation are independent of whether Article 56A is compatible with EU law. The defensible character of an expert opinion, on the criteria Vienna set out, is judged on the material existing when the opinion was delivered. A preliminary ruling on the compatibility of Article 56A would be given after that opinion. The interpretation sought does not meet an objective need for the resolution of the dispute, and it is not necessary for that resolution. There is no connecting factor of the kind the case law requires. The request is treated as seeking advisory opinions on general or hypothetical questions, and it is inadmissible.
The judgment therefore does not hold Article 56A compatible with EU law, and it does not hold it incompatible. iGaming Business reports that press officer Jacques René Zammit told the paper the judgment did not go into that question, and that other cases now before the Court could produce a ruling on it. The first of those sentences matches the judgment. This desk has not opened a list of the other cases.
Malta had asked, by a document lodged on 8 May 2026, for the oral part to be reopened. It said that if the Court held the reference admissible and answered the questions, as the Advocate General had contemplated in the alternative in his Opinion, Malta should be able to reply at a hearing to the written observations of the other parties. It invoked Article 47 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights. The Court refused. It said the written procedure and the oral part had given it every element required, and that Malta had relied on no new fact capable of exercising a decisive influence. It also said Article 47 does not impose an absolute obligation to hold a public hearing, and does not require a hearing in every case.