The court heard the ban. Fux left it standing.
He said some of the questions can be settled outside the court. If he has to decide, he said the court should act with rationality and prudence.
- Hearing
- 3 November 2026, from 10:00, in the Second Panel's session room at the Supreme Federal Court, Brasília. Rapporteur Luiz Fux. The court's newsroom calls it the second public hearing on betting. This paper already recorded the 28 October timetable.
- Case
- ADI 8027, brought by ANJL against the president and Congress. The court also lists ADIs 8024, 8028 and 8035 against the same measure, and ADIs 7721, 7723 and 7749 against Law 14.790/2023.
- Health minister
- Alexandre Padilha, as the court summarised him: SUS demand tied to gambling disorder up more than 200 percent from 2018 to 2026, and 40 percent of 1.2 million people who asked to be self-excluded reported losing control. Those figures are the minister's.
- Clubs
- Fluminense put the hit on that club at R$200 million. Cruzeiro said operators had paid more than R$30 million for five-year authorisations cut short. The Olympic committee's lawyer put betting transfers at about R$130 million, a fifth of the 2027 budget as planned. Those figures are the speakers'.
- Close
- Fux repeated that there is no fundamental right to run games of chance, from his vote in Extraordinary Appeal 966177. He did not grant an injunction and did not name a day for judgment.
Justice Luiz Fux has sat Brazil’s second public hearing on the ban on fixed-odds betting, and he has not lifted it. The session ran on 3 November in the Second Panel’s room at the Supreme Federal Court in Brasília. iGaming Business reported the day on 4 November. The court’s own newsroom, which this desk opened, records that Fux closed the hearing the same evening. This paper had already filed the 28 October timetable. The hearing is a later event.
The government used the morning and the afternoon to defend Provisional Measure 1,394. Wellington César Lima e Silva, the justice minister, told the court that harm to health, public security and families justified the state’s intervention, and that regulation had proved too thin. iGaming Business records him calling the platforms an “architecture of unspeakable dependency” and the measure “relevant and urgent.” Those two phrases are the outlet’s. Attorney General Jorge Messias argued that the earlier statutes, Laws 13.756/2018 and 14.790/2023, had not given the protection the constitution requires. iGaming Business has him saying the framework had become “materially unconstitutional due to insufficient protection of constitutionally protected assets.” Health Minister Alexandre Padilha, as the court summarised him, put SUS demand tied to gambling disorder up more than 200 percent between 2018 and 2026, and said 40 percent of 1.2 million people who asked to be self-excluded reported losing control of their bets. Those counts are the minister’s. The court did not check them in the news post.
Football spent its ten-minute slots on contracts the measure had already cut. Fluminense, through Matheus Reis e Montenegro, put the hit on that club at R$200 million and warned of jobs in the smaller sides and in Série B. Cruzeiro, through José Francisco Cimino Manssur, said a sponsor had been authorised for five years and was stopped in fewer than two, and that operators had paid more than R$30 million for licences the state was keeping. Flamengo’s vice-president, Flávio de Araújo Willeman, asked who would pay for sponsorships signed under a statute Congress had passed. Botafogo said ten days was not a transition, and that women’s football and the academy sat inside the lost money. The Olympic committee’s lawyer put betting transfers at about R$130 million, a fifth of the 2027 budget as planned. Those figures are the speakers’.
The licensed trade asked Fux to keep a market, or at least a clock. Pietro Cardia Lorenzoni, for ANJL, the plaintiff in ADI 8027, said prohibition does not end betting, and that deposits in the last three months of 2026 analysed against 2025 were down 32 percent under the licensed regime. That percentage is ANJL’s. Celso Cintra Mori, for the Brazilian Institute of Responsible Gaming, told the court the country had chosen regulated play after years in Congress, and that the measure undoes good-faith legal relations. iGaming Business reports that IBJR asked for an injunction that would freeze the measure until Congress votes or the court rules on the merits. The court’s own summary of Mori does not print that request. Marcello Trindade, for UERJ’s economic-regulation laboratory, offered a 180-to-360-day transition if the measure stands, and, if the market reopens, betting limits by tax number, advertising curbs, stronger self-exclusion, and money for prevention and treatment in SUS.
Fux did not grant the pause. He repeated a line from his vote in Extraordinary Appeal 966177: there is no fundamental right to run games of chance. At the close he said the speakers had brought material the 2024 hearing had not, on economic impact, illegal betting, organised crime, athletes’ rights and legal certainty. Some of those questions, he said, can be settled outside the judiciary. If the court has to decide, it should act with rationality and prudence. Nothing in the court’s posts of 3 November suspends the measure or names a day for judgment. Congress still has the joint committee on the text awaiting installation, as this paper has already recorded.