Fux stays every ordinary case on Brazil’s betting ban.
The prosecutor asked on 6 November, the day an appeals court shut CDA’s window. Fux signed on Sunday.
- Order
- Brasília, 8 November 2026. Justice Luiz Fux, rapporteur, Direct Action of Unconstitutionality 8027. The court’s newsroom posted it on 9 November, timestamped 08:49.
- The stay
- Every ongoing case in the ordinary courts that discusses the constitutionality of Provisional Measure 1,394/2026. It runs until a final judgment of that dispute in ADIs 8024, 8027, 8028 and 8035. Ad referendum of the Plenary. The newsroom says the order is already in force.
- The request
- Prosecutor-General Paulo Gonet, 6 November 2026, eDoc 472. Incidental provisional relief to stay, nationwide, cases about the constitutionality of the measure of 25 September 2026.
- Two files he named
- Stake Brazil, 5030862-66.2026.4.03.6100, an injunction of 8 October that let the firm keep operating until 25 October. CDA Gaming, interlocutory appeal 5034200-15.2026.4.03.0000, a single-judge order of 3 November for Casa de Apostas, Betsul and Jogo Online. The petition also lists thirteen files. The Stake case is the first of them. The CDA appeal sits outside that list.
- Still ahead
- The Plenary confirms the stay. The order does not decide the four direct actions. This paper has already filed the 3 November hearing and the 6 November freeze of the CDA order.
Justice Luiz Fux has stayed every ordinary-court case in Brazil that asks whether the ban on fixed-odds betting is constitutional. He signed the order in Brasília on 8 November 2026, in Direct Action of Unconstitutionality 8027. SBC News reported it on 9 November. The court’s newsroom posted the same morning, timestamped 08:49. This desk opened that post and the signed decision.
The order suspends all ongoing proceedings in the ordinary courts that discuss the constitutionality of Provisional Measure 1,394/2026. The stay lasts until the Supreme Federal Court gives a final judgment on that dispute in ADIs 8024, 8027, 8028 and 8035. Fux granted it ad referendum of the Plenary. The newsroom says the order is already in force and will go to the full bench for confirmation. It leaves the measure itself for that later judgment.
The request came from Prosecutor-General Paulo Gonet on 6 November, filed as eDoc 472. He asked for incidental provisional relief to stay, nationwide, the cases whose object is the constitutionality of the measure of 25 September 2026. He wrote that some ordinary courts had granted urgent relief in individual suits and had suspended the measure on the view that it is unconstitutional. He named two. On 8 October the Federal Court in São Paulo, in case 5030862-66.2026.4.03.6100, let Stake Brazil keep operating as a betting house until 25 October. On 3 November a single judge, in interlocutory appeal 5034200-15.2026.4.03.0000, suspended the measure for CDA Gaming and allowed Casa de Apostas, Betsul and Jogo Online to operate. The petition then lists thirteen files in which the effects of the measure are in dispute. The Stake case is the first name on that list. The CDA appeal is cited beside it, and is not one of the thirteen. This paper has already filed the end of Stake’s window and the 6 November order that froze the CDA relief. Gonet’s petition is dated that same Friday.
Fux took the risk Gonet described. Decisions that point different ways, he wrote, would leave the law uncertain. The further harm, in his words, would be the possible release of an activity he treats as already recognised to be harmful, and of high social risk: the running of fixed-odds bets. He pointed to what he had said at the public hearing on 3 November, and to his vote in Extraordinary Appeal 966177, in the Plenary session of 6 August 2026. He found both requirements for a provisional order, periculum in mora and fumus boni iuris: danger in delay, and a plausible legal case.
He issued the stay alone, and he set out why one justice may do that. A provisional order in a direct action can come from the rapporteur, subject to the Plenary. He used article 21 of Law 9.868/1999, which lets the court, by an absolute majority, tell judges and tribunals to suspend cases about the norm under review in a declaratory action of constitutionality, until the final judgment. He recalled article 5, paragraph 1, of Law 9.882/1999, which lets a rapporteur grant an injunction in a claim of non-compliance with a fundamental precept when the case is extremely urgent, when serious harm is close, or during a recess, subject to the full court. He treated a direct action and that claim as close enough, inside the concentrated control of constitutionality, that the same provisional regime should apply. He also relied on article 21, items IV and V, of the court’s internal rules. Those items let the rapporteur, in an urgent case, order the provisional measures needed to protect a right exposed to serious harm, or to secure the effect of a later judgment, subject to the Plenary or a panel. The newsroom’s line is the practical one. The stay is already running. The Plenary still confirms it.
The door the order closes is the ordinary-court door. A firm that wants a judge to lift the ban now waits on those four direct actions. This paper has already recorded that Fux closed the 3 November hearing without suspending the measure.