Dino has given the full court back the games-of-chance file.
Fux has already voted to keep the 1941 offence. A joint sitting with the betting ban and the municipal lotteries is still only a discussion.
- The return
- 12 November 2026. Justice Flávio Dino. Extraordinary Appeal 966177, Theme 924 of general repercussion. The docket records a return of the vista and, timestamped 00:00:03, an automatic listing for in-person merits at the Plenary under Internal-Rules Amendment 58 of 19 December 2022. Rapporteur: Justice Luiz Fux. This desk opened that docket.
- The case
- Ministério Público of Rio Grande do Sul against Guilherme Tarigo Heinz. Origin: 1st Criminal Appeals Panel of the Rio Grande do Sul Court of Justice. Protocol 26 April 2016. The question is whether article 50, caput, of the Law of Criminal Contravenções, Decree-Law 3.688/1941, was received by the 1988 Constitution.
- Fux's vote
- Plenary, 6 August 2026. Fux would grant the appeal, declare that article 50 was received, restore the first-instance conviction, and fix this thesis for Theme 924: the contravention of exploiting a game of chance in article 50, caput, of Decree-Law 3.688/1941, in the form of Decree-Law 9.215/1946, was received by the 1988 Constitution. Dino then asked for the file. Alexandre de Moraes was absent. Presidency: Edson Fachin.
- Municipal lotteries
- ADPF 1212, rapporteur Nunes Marques. Plenary, 4 November 2026. After the report and the oral arguments, Fachin suspended the sitting. The court's newsroom the same afternoon said it would resume on a later day. Solidariedade brought the action. A December 2025 injunction already froze municipal lottery laws and operations.
- Still ahead
- No date on the RE 966177 calendar after the return. iGaming Business reports that, at the 4 November sitting, Dino asked for a joint reading with the betting files, Fux agreed, and Fachin said the presidency's stance was a separate judgment but that he was open to a joint session. The 4 November certificate records only the suspension after the speeches. This paper has already filed the 3 November hearing on Provisional Measure 1,394 and the 8 November nationwide stay of ordinary challenges.
Justice Flávio Dino has sent Extraordinary Appeal 966177 back to Brazil’s full court. He returned the file on 12 November. iGaming Business reported the step on 13 November. This desk opened the docket.
The entry is a return of a vista. The same line records that the appeal has been listed automatically for an in-person merits sitting of the Plenary, under Internal-Rules Amendment 58 of 19 December 2022, timestamped 00:00:03. The calendar tab on that page still shows no sitting after 6 August. The president of the court, Justice Edson Fachin, names the day.
The appeal is Theme 924 of general repercussion. Luiz Fux is the rapporteur. The Ministério Público of Rio Grande do Sul is the appellant. Guilherme Tarigo Heinz is the respondent. The case came from the 1st Criminal Appeals Panel of the Rio Grande do Sul Court of Justice, and it was protocolled on 26 April 2016. The question is whether article 50, caput, of the Law of Criminal Contravenções, Decree-Law 3.688 of 1941, was received by the 1988 Constitution. That article makes it a contravention to set up or run a game of chance in a public place, or a place the public can reach.
The Plenary opened the merits on 5 August and continued on 6 August. Fux voted to grant the appeal. He would declare that article 50 was received, set aside the appeals-panel judgment that had treated the offence as not received and had acquitted the defendant, and restore the first-instance conviction. He proposed this thesis: the contravention of exploiting a game of chance, in article 50, caput, of Decree-Law 3.688/1941, in the form of Decree-Law 9.215/1946, was received by the 1988 Constitution. Dino then asked for the file. Alexandre de Moraes was absent. Fachin presided. Those lines are the certificate of 6 August.
A later sitting is the other half of the story iGaming Business tells. On 4 November the Plenary began ADPF 1212, the claim by Solidariedade against municipal laws that create or run lotteries, including sports lotteries. Nunes Marques is the rapporteur. He had already frozen those municipal norms and the operations under them. After the report and the speeches, Fachin suspended the sitting. The court’s newsroom that afternoon said it would resume on a later day. The certificate names the speakers and records only that suspension.
iGaming Business reports that, in that sitting, Dino recalled he had asked for a joint reading of the files on games of chance, municipal lotteries and the betting statutes, that Fux, who also reports the actions on Law 14.790/2023 and on Provisional Measure 1,394, agreed, and that Fachin said the presidency’s stance was a separate judgment but that he was open to a joint session at an opportune moment. The paper also has Fux saying he needs more time for a vote that covers the points those files raise. The 4 November certificate does not print those remarks. No order on the RE 966177 docket joins the cases.
The betting ban itself is still the measure this paper has already filed. Fux closed the 3 November public hearing without lifting Provisional Measure 1,394. He stayed the ordinary-court challenges on 8 November. Congress has added sixty days. None of that is a merits vote on whether the 1941 offence still stands, or on whether cities may run lotteries. Those votes wait on a day Fachin has not named.